LIMIT 3 PER ORDER. Please note, placing multiple orders greatly increases the chances of receiving duplicate pins. 

The late, great Ronnie James Dio once said, "It's always a mystery..."

And that's exactly what the Pin of Mystery is. Simply choose how many and we will send you a enamel pin. It could be a discontinued pin, or even one of our coveted limited editions. You'll never know what you're going to get.

The mystery is yours to solve by opening your mailbox and revealing what is inside... if you dare! If you're still not sure what this is, or have questions, take a look below for more information.

WHAT PINS ARE INCLUDED?
Many different pin designs make up the Pin of Mystery. They could be anything from our horror pin collection, discontinued items, overstocked items, and even some rare out of print limited editions!

CAN I REQUEST A SPECIFIC PIN?
I'm afraid not. That's all part of the fun. You like to have fun, don't you?

CAN I RETURN OR EXCHANGE THE PIN IF I DON'T LIKE IT OR ALREADY OWN IT?
I'm sorry, but we cannot accept any returns, or exchanges on Pin of Mystery. Part of the fun is not knowing what it is. If you don't like the pin, or already own it, then share the love and give it to a friend!